![]() |
| Debut novel now available! |
As I mentioned in my Insecure Writers post on Wednesday, there are moments when the aspiring writer seeking traditional publication questions whether or not they will ever achieve that goal of finding an agent or editor. We all know perseverance is a huge part of the equation, but I don't think you know what real perseverance looks like unless you know Lisa Regan's story. Here, in her own words, is her journey:
The Elusive Agent
On 4/12/06 I sent out my first batch of queries. 7 of them. By 4/25/06 I had three full requests out to agents and a
telephone call from one of them telling me how much she loved my book and that
she loved how “gritty and dark” it was.
I thought: this is it! It’s only been 2 weeks and I’ve already gotten a phone
call! I’m going to get an agent
soon! I might just go down in
history as the fastest agent-getter ever! Right?
Not so much.
4 and a half years, 2
books and 238 agent rejections later I finally landed an agent.
What went wrong?
Why did it take so long?
How could I generate that much interest in 2 weeks and not land an agent
right away?
In short: my book wasn’t ready.
It had the makings of a good story but it wasn’t ready. This was before the proliferation of
agent and writer blogs, before forums and online writing groups. My biggest mistake was not using
critique partners or beta readers. My first real critique came from an actual agent. It was a glowing rejection that was 7
paragraphs long. I made every
change he suggested and asked him to give it another look. He did and said it was better but it
wasn’t quite there yet. I actually
got this from many agents: “It’s
great but it’s not quite there.
Let me look it over and get you some notes.” Well that never happened. Agents are ridiculously busy, and I can tell you that their
clients always take priority. I
never got those notes from any of the agents that promised them. Eventually they got to feeling badly
for never getting back to me and simply passed. Really, you have to do the work yourself.
What else have I learned about landing that elusive
agent? Behold:
Writing Another Book
is a Good Idea: Keep writing
while you’re querying. It keeps
you from going crazy in agent-rejection hell. Many times, agents who liked your first book but rejected it
anyway will read your second book based on having liked the first. I got a lot of requests for Finding Claire Fletcher. Once I had written my second book, I
went back to the agents who gave me nice rejections and I said hey, remember
me? You liked my first book but
passed on it? Well I’ve got
another one, want to read it?
(More eloquently than that, of course). Every single one of them said send it right over.
Send Out A Lot of
Queries: I always read about
people who are ready to jump off the nearest bridge after sending out 4 queries and
getting 4 rejections. From the
other side of 238 rejections, I can tell you that you should not let 4
rejections get you down. Certainly,
it’s discouraging. I mean who
doesn’t want to go 4 for 4? But
it’s not the end of the world.
Getting an agent is hard. Some
agents get between 50-100 queries a day. It’s extremely difficult to stand out
from the crowd. I think a more
realistic number to get upset about is 25 rejections. If you’ve sent out 25 queries and gotten 25 rejections without any requests then
you probably need to rework your query.
Query Widely. Really. I know everything and everyone says to choose your top five
dream agents and only query them.
You’re supposed to choose agents who represent the same type of books as
yours, similar authors blah blah blah.
Okay, so you should do that, but you also shouldn’t ignore agents who
cast a wider net. Don’t count out
the agents who simply list “commercial fiction” under their submission
guidelines. Or agents who typically
represent genres A, B and C but have sold one or two books that are similar to
yours. Often they are more likely
to give your book a chance.
That Said, Do Your
Research: Don’t query agents
who expressly state that they do not represent books like yours. Also, follow submission guidelines on
agent websites. Read the fine
print. Follow directions. You’re asking these people to take your
book baby and find a good home for it.
That’s a tall order. The
least you can do is follow their directions.
Publishers Marketplace
is a Great Resource. You have
to pay if you want the daily updates but it’s only $20 a month and I used this
more than any other resource. You’ll
get weekly emails letting you know who has moved, who has opened their new
agency and who has left the business.
You’ll also get an email daily listing what deals have been made that
day. It’s not comprehensive
because not everyone reports to PM but it’s still pretty useful. You get to see who is selling
what. That is actually how I found
my agent. She popped up a few
times as having sold books in my genre.
I Googled her, followed her submission guidelines when sending my query
and the rest, as they say, is history.
Don’t Give Up. It takes time. It’s frustrating as hell. But if you keep working at it—keep
writing, keep honing your craft and keep putting yourself out there—great
things can happen!
Synopsis for Finding Claire Fletcher:
Lisa Regan is a suspense novelist. She has a Bachelor’s Degree in English
and Master of Education Degree from Bloomsburg University. She lives in Philadelphia with her
husband and daughter.
Synopsis for Finding Claire Fletcher:
Down on
his luck, Detective Connor Parks takes solace in the arms of a woman he meets
at a local bar, but in the morning, Claire Fletcher is gone, leaving behind
clues to a decade-old mystery. Abducted at age fifteen, no one has heard from
Claire Fletcher in ten years. Until
now. Driven by an
unsettling need to see Claire again, Connor sets out to solve the mystery of her disappearance once and for all.
Never Give Up, Never Surrender!!
.
Lisa's novel, Finding Claire Fletcher, is now available from these locations:
Never Give Up, Never Surrender!!
.


Congratulations, Lisa!!!
ReplyDeleteAnd if you lived through 238 rejections, then quitting after fifty isn't an option.
Looking forward to reading your book.
Thank you Alex! :)
DeleteWhat an inspiring story and a great reminder not to give up. Congratulations Lisa :)
ReplyDeleteThank you so much!
Deletean encouraging story for people who haven't been published yet.
ReplyDeleteThank you so much! I hope mine is the worst-case scenario and it doesn't take others quite as long! LOL
DeleteAlex - Amazing. I gave up after thirty queries once. :P
ReplyDeletemshatch - I am such a wuss compared to her. Really.
Dezzy - FOUR years of querying is...wow. Yeah, she really inspires me. And I can't wait to read her novel.
Great post, Lisa. Good on your for sticking with it, and congratulations!
ReplyDeleteThank you Jeff!
DeleteVery very inspiring. Thank you both for sharing.
ReplyDeletekaren
Thank you for stopping by, Karen!
DeleteNot only a great story of perseverance, but excellent tips from the road as well. Congrats, and thanks for the advice!
ReplyDeleteThank you! Thanks for stopping by!
DeleteJeff - You know how big of a deal this is to Lisa. It's actually an eight year journey she's been on to see this novel written and published. Wow.
ReplyDeleteKaren - I will never complain about getting a handful of rejections again!
MC - This girl is tough! She's a Road Warrior in the agent pursuit game. :P
Wow, I am duly impressed with Lisa's determination. A true inspiration to those of us who turn wimpy after fifty or so rejections. This book sounds wonderful, and I wish it much success.
ReplyDeleteYeah, fifty rejections sounds sort of wimpy in comparison, right?
DeleteWow! That's an intense story of perseverance! I am totally impressed and amazed. I agree with the writing while waiting part. I used to write one short story and then send it out and wait until I heard something back. Now I just keep writing and writing and writing, that way when the rejection comes or the ocassional acceptance, I have other projects going and it's less of an emotional roller coaster.
ReplyDeleteWay to Go Lisa!
Thank you, Tyrean! Yes, the writing always kept me from going nuts! LOL.
DeleteL.G. - Thank you so very much for all your kind words and for hosting me! I'm very grateful!!!
ReplyDeleteI appreciate your candor in writing about your journey to land an agent. That's a lot of rejections to handle. I'm so happy for you that you finally experienced success, and your book sounds very exciting.
ReplyDeleteMichael: thanks for stopping by! Yes, it was a lot to handle. Many, many times I wanted to throw in the towel altogether!
DeleteTyrean - When I was querying (two previous projects) I was always so obsessed with the process that I couldn't focus on writing. Such a mistake. It really does ease some of the pressure if you've got another writing project to look forward to. Ugh, I hate querying.
ReplyDeleteLIsa - Thank you for sharing your great story. I mean, that's a LOT of rejection. Most people wouldn't be able to withstand that sort of rejection and keep going. I think it's incredible that you believed in yourself and your project enough to tell the naysayers to go to hell. Wishing you so much luck with the release of your debut novel!!!
Michael - Can you imagine getting over two hundred "no's" and keep going? Tough, tough, tough.
You are so wonderful to me, Luanne! :)
DeleteLisa's story is so inspiring! I think this is the best story of perseverance I've ever heard. Lisa's book is fantastic and the fact that she went through so much to get to this point makes it even better. Great post, Lisa and LG!
ReplyDeleteJulie - I agree. That is one determined woman. :)
DeleteAwww . . . thanks Julie! I really appreciate it! :)
DeleteGreat tips!! I personally think querying is the worst and hardest part of a writer's career. But we just have to persevere if we want that shining goal at the end.
ReplyDeleteOh, I agree. Hates it, Precious! Hates it. But we gotta do it, and somehow learn to let the rejection roll off like LIsa did. Next time I query I'm wearing battle armor. :P
DeleteLynda: Querying absolutely IS the worst part and the hardest part!!!! But if you can get past it, it's all uphill from there (so far anyway!) :) Thanks for your comment!
DeleteCongratulations, Lisa! Love your tips, especially don't give up. There's always hope around the corner, even if it takes 80 miles to get there. Having determination and a set mind helps, but there are too many distractions in this world to just CONCENTRATE on writing.
ReplyDeleteI love writing so much, but I didn't take it seriously until this year. You learn so much from your fellow writers! And seeing their successes give you hope and jealously, but what matters is that you have the WRITTEN WORD in commnon.
Thanks Luanne for having Lisa over here! Loved this post! :)
Livia - It was my pleasure to have Lisa on the blog today. I love her story, and she is one of the most supportive people in the blogosphere. Can't wait to read her novel, which I'll start soon. :)
DeleteThank you so much Livia! I can only hope that my worst-case-scenario querying journey will help other writers in some way!
DeleteYou're a fine example of perseverance, Lisa. Thanks for sharing your publication story. I'm glad you stuck with it. You're a fine writer!
ReplyDelete*waves to LG*
Emily - waves. And I'm glad she stuck with it too. Started reading it, and it looks like it's going to be intense.
DeleteThank you so much Emily! I appreciate the kind words!
DeleteI love Lisa's story. It is so inspirational! And she gave some great tips, too!
ReplyDeleteYeah, I think for anyone who is seeking an agent they really do need to subscribe to Publisher's Marketplace to keep up with where agents and editors are and track what they're selling.
DeleteThanks Lara! If there's anything I can do to help you with your forthcoming release, let me know! :)
DeleteThanks Lisa, for the querying tips. Great advice and we need to hear it from those who experience it. The book sounds intriguing, especially since so many people go 'missing'.
ReplyDeleteAnd, Luanne, something changed here. No more LG, but a more personal touch, I see. A little change is good. Thanks for featuring Lisa!
I saw a reference to or from that other L.G. the other day so yeah, I think the Luanne is good. Thanks so much for stopping by and reading my post, D.G.!
DeleteReal perseverance and self belief, yes these do seem to be vital for successful authorship and so tough too!
ReplyDeleteGreat advice and a great post. x
Thanks so much for stopping by!
DeleteD.G. - Lisa's book is about a woman who was abducted as a child, and she and I have a weird sort of fascination with these kinds of stories. Can't imagine how she wrote a novel from that perspective, but I'm interested to read it.
ReplyDeleteAnd I decided to update things with my first name because there's another blogger/writer who goes by LG and it started getting a little confusing I think. :)
Madeleine - That's the other part we need aside from perseverance -- believing in what we're doing enough to withstand the barrage of no's we get thrown at us. So true.
Luanne, please may I have permission to print this and hang it on my wall as a reminder when times get rough? I'm no where near completion of my book so I'm sure this will be long forgotten by then and after a few rejections I know I'll feel like dirt. This served as a great reminder to keep on trucking. Thank you!!
ReplyDeleteYeah, we could all use this as a reminder when it's time to query. That number of 238 queries just astounds me. Seriously, considering how much work and research went into sending out that many letters and then to have them all be rejected is just crazy. So glad she had a happy ending. :)
DeleteThank you kindly - consider it printing now. No, really, copied, pasted, printed =)
DeleteElsie: I'm so flattered that my story would be encouraging to you--but that's what I hope it does, encourage other writers to keep going when it seems like madness to do so! Never say never!
ReplyDeleteA few years ago, Lisa gave me some great advice. She said, there may be 1000 doors, but all it takes is one. So keep on knocking until you find it. Now, I didn't take quite the same path, but the message still related. Never quit. You only lose if you don't try. Lisa & I have been through a lot together. She will forever be my hero!
ReplyDeleteAwww . . . you're so going to make me cry! Thank you, as always for your wonderful words!
DeleteLisa = I have been following your path to publication for some time, and remember seeing images of those 200+ rejections on your blog. The fact that you kept going gives me huge encouragement as I work toward seeing my own novel get published. In the meantime, I already have a copy of your book and look forward to reading it!
ReplyDeleteI am confident you'll get there, Ellis! Thank you so much for your support and for purchasing and reading my book! It means a lot to me!
DeleteGreat post. Wow. I'm not even up to 100 queries yet, so I've got plenty of work ahead of me!
ReplyDeleteYes, don't let it get you down! Like Nancy said above, it only takes one yes to open the door!
DeleteNancy - You've both been through the gauntlet, but came out the other side published. :D
ReplyDeleteEllis - It really does make you step back and try and gain a new perspective on the process.
Milo - You and Lisa both are the poster children for perseverance in the face of rejection. And with successful outcomes! :))
Really great post. I appreciate your honesty about the rejections and the way you approached the agents that were kind about it.
ReplyDeleteWhat a roller coaster ride for her, right? Going from requests and a phone call to 238 rejections. Crazy how subjective this business is.
DeleteCongratulations, Lisa. Your perseverance is inspiring. Thank you for sharing your story.
ReplyDeleteThank you! Thanks for stopping by!
DeleteThank you! Thanks for stopping by!
DeleteAwesome post! Perseverance is everything in this gig. ;)
ReplyDeleteIt certainly is! Thank you!
DeleteThis sounds like a great read! I really admire Lisa's hard work and determination! Thanks for hosting Luanne! Julie
ReplyDeleteThank you very much! And yes, thanks Luanne for hosting me!
DeleteHow right you are Lisa, don't give up and I admire you so much for keeping at it. They do say that we should write one and sub one. I must say it was excellent that you got a critique from an agent - that's as rare as hen's teeth!
ReplyDeleteYes, it was one of the best critiques I've ever gotten! LOL. Thanks for reading!
DeleteKari Marie - It's one of the neat things about being connected to so many other writers online. We get to share our experiences and learn from others.
ReplyDeleteNicole - Everything!! Oh, and coffee and chocolate too. :)
ENI - It really is the coolest thing to see someone work so hard for something...and then get it. :)
Susan - Write one Sub one is such a great philosophy for writers. The more we write the more we have to offer, and that's a good thing.