I watched an interesting documentary the other night called Get a Life. Written and directed by William Shatner, the show took a look at the culture of Trekkies, those people who continue to venture out to Star Trek conventions nearly fifty years after the original show first aired in 1966.
It's funny that Shatner, who also wrote a book by the same name, got the title from a Saturday Night Live skit he did where he mocked the nerdy stereotype of the show's most ardent fans. I think for many years that was his view of those who came to see him at conventions. But that's not what the documentary ended up being about. It got much more interesting, especially for those of us who write about heroes.
The question Shatner wanted to ask was why? Why do people continue to LOVE a television show to the degree they do all these years later?
At first you're introduced to people arriving at a convention dressed in their Star Trek shirts, Vulcan ears, and Klingon forehead prosthetics. And perhaps you respond with a predictable groan as they parade past the camera waving their Spock salutes. But then the documentary goes a little deeper and you learn about the individuals, their situations at home, their reasons for coming, and how, for a few, their lives were altered in sometimes dramatic ways through their relationship with the show and its characters.
And then, once you get a feel for who these fans are, the whole documentary shifts into the framework of storytelling and the mythos of hero. When Shatner sits down to speak with Robert Walter, President of the Joseph Campbell Foundation (by the way, if you don't know who Joseph Campbell is, you really need to go read about the Hero's Journey now), they discuss how television, when it was new, became the "hearth" from which modern stories were told. But there is more going on than simple admiration for an entertaining story among these Trekkies.
In fact, Walters goes so far as to say that the people who raise their fandom to the level of participating in conventions are "buying into a narrative, a mythology, that helps them figure out how to relate to other human beings and their tribe." Also, that brand of "rabid fandom" doesn't occur unless the myth/hero being admired "speaks to the common human experience." In the case of Star Trek, it embodies the spirit of a society that doesn't exclude people based on race or gender, as we see experienced by a crew who care deeply about each other's welfare. All are welcome from whatever corner of the universe, and that is a powerful message that can continue to resonate into the future.
As a storyteller I found this very enlightening. I mean, people write about all sorts of characters and heroic situations, but most never reach that level of fanaticism or capture the imagination of multiple generations. And yet stories like Star Trek, Star Wars, Harry Potter, Lord of the Rings, The Wizard of Oz, and, yes, even Twilight and The Hunger Games have all somehow hit that vein by touching on universal themes that people recognize and want to exalt.
Joseph Campbell once said, "The myths of tomorrow are in the psyches of the artists today."
So how can you ever know as a writer if you're tapping into something that universal with your story? Can you even seek it out? Or is it a matter of writing the best story you can and leaving the rest up to The Force?
And just for fun, what's your favorite Star Trek episode? Because I know you're a nerd like me.
Can't help it, I'm a fan of the Gorn episode. Such a metaphor for life, don't you think? Everything we need is there for us, if we can only figure out how to put it together. :)
.

I still haven't watched that, but I do remember his rant on SNL.
ReplyDeleteStar Trek has always tapped into the human equation. Yes, we all wish we could write stories like that.
Off the top of my head... probably an episode from Next Gen would be my favorite, The Best of Both Worlds.
I do think he came to regret that rant just a little. Maybe hit too much of a nerve with people.
DeleteFascinating. :-)
ReplyDeleteI never thought of the social impact. But I do remember seeing one special where the actress who played Uhura said she was going to quit, and Martin Luther King told her not to - that she could do more for the cause of civil rights by playing her role and showing people of color being respected.
And for favorite episode, probably "Shore Leave." Or this one.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?feature=player_detailpage&v=szS3SJDaBGc#t=28s
MC - Oh, there's a scene with the Uhura actress where she talks about having a skinhead in London come up to her and say that after he watched Star Trek he realized what an ass he was and thanked her for being on the show. And you know she and Kirk shared the first biracial kiss on television! So strange to think that was a big deal at the time.
DeleteI haven't seen it either but I'm pretty sure I've seen every single Star Trek episode. I particularly like the one where Spock is compelled to steal the Enterprise to get married and thinks he kills Kirk but then is almost happy when he finds out he didn't.
ReplyDeleteYes! That's one of my other favorites where Spock has to deal with his Vulcan sex ritual. HIlarious.
DeleteI don't think he has the right to mock the fans since he exists mostly because of them, I don't remember any other of his roles outside the STAR TREK films and show.
ReplyDeleteTrekkies and other extreme fantasy fans are interesting from the psychological point of view because most of them do this as a way of escape from the world they live in and space and galaxy are their way out. There's nothing bad in this, all of us have our ways to relax and leave our surroundings even for an hour or so, but it gets bad when they start wearing the costumes in real life :)
I've never watched the old series, I'm too young for those :) I grew up with NEXT GENERATION and later on watched and loved VOYAGER and ENTERPRISE and hated DS9 which is overly violent, morbid, dark and infused with pompous philosophy and religion.
He did do a cop show in the eighties too, TJ Hooker, but he most definitely owes his enduring fame to Star Trek, which I think he realizes. I suspect the book and the documentary were a way of trying a mea culpa.
DeleteAnd it's also interesting that the mythology expert thought the people who dress up are actually participating in the creative process by injecting themselves into the story in a way.
This is a wonderful and thought-provoking essay, L.G. Guess I'm one of those who just writes the story and leaves it to the Force whether it ties in to universal themes.
ReplyDeleteKaren
Oh, me too, Karen. I would love to find a universal theme like that to write and have people connect to, but I get a little too focused on individual characters and their smaller problems. :)
DeleteGreat post! For the last several years, my teenaged daughter and her peers have spent a lot of time debating who would win battles between Star Wars characters and Star Trek characters. It's pretty much a tie. Cool that shows I watched as a child are important to teens now. For Star Trek, I agree it's the idea of inclusion.
ReplyDeleteReally? You all think it would be a tie? Hmmm, I kind of think the Star Wars characters might kick butt in an actual battle, but then again those Star Trek guys are full of "try harder' so who knows. :P
DeleteI agree with Desmond. It always irritated me that Shatner would mock and demean the fans that put him on that pedestal.
ReplyDeleteFavorite ST episode? I've watched every episode on every series. I think my favorite was the one where they melded DS9 with the original series to make "Trials and Tribble-ations".
The spliced in new characters were hilarious set into the old series.
I wonder if, from his point of view, it really was just a television series -- a job he did to earn money -- not realizing those bigger themes were resonating with the audience the way they were. I think he gets it now.
DeleteAnd I remember the Tribbles. That's another great one. :)
As a Trekker (not a Trekkie) since I first saw the show, I can say I fell in the love with the world it created. While it may have been a space opera, a Horatio Hornblower in Space, it was still rich in possibilities.
ReplyDeleteI've never dressed as a character or attended a convention. Can't say that about Harry Potter. lol
Yes, I definitely connected to that theme of universal acceptance. Where else on television at the time did you see women being treated almost equally in a high stress/high risk job? And the multiculturalism of the show wasn't lost on my young worldview either. :)
DeleteAlso, you need to post pics of you in Potter-wear. :P
Great post, Luanne. It makes us think deeper into the psyche behind the aspects of fandom. Thank goodness this documentary is on Netflix. I'll watch it soon. While being a "fanatic" may set one up to ridicule, it also shows how deeply the narrative has touched the reader/viewer. Talk about enduring impact.
ReplyDeleteIt's only about an hour long, but it did make me think about how to create those sort of enduring stories that really touch people inside. Not sure how to write one, but I appreciate it when others do. :)
DeleteLu, this was an excellent post. I wonder if for those universal forces to alight, the psyche of the writer has to be looking for open (actively open) or more blithe and simply loving what they do.
ReplyDeleteIt probably happens to both types and neither without rhyme or reason ...
Yeah, I wonder if Roddenberry (or other writers) are aware of those themes, or if they just write the story they have inside them and it ends up being universal. I mean, he had to know that he was going to hit a nerve by showing a multi-racial crew during the Civil Rights era. I think that was a deliberate poke in society's eye.
DeleteOh Captain Kirk. :-) I think it is all about doing the best we can and when we do...The Force will come and help us go a little further!
ReplyDeleteHe is rather awesome, is he not? I admit to my young girl crush on the captain ( from watching reruns!! I'm not that old).
DeleteI think the greatest need we have as humans is to belong to a group. Most people have families or church groups that fulfill that basic need for them but for many of us who have felt marginalized for one reason or another groups that work for a common good and include a fair share of people who are different are most attractive.
ReplyDeleteMy favorite episodes are those that had to do with the Borg. I was always fascinated with the idea of the collective.
That's exactly what I was thinking while I watched. There are so many disenfranchised people in society, and when a show or story pushes a theme of acceptance, it's going to resonate as a powerful message with those who feel they've been pushed to the outside. We all want to feel like we belong somewhere.
DeleteActors tend to look at what they do as work. They go in and do the best job they can but it's still a job and they can disconnect from it and move on to the next. Fans...they're a puzzle when they get stuck on one body of an actor's work. The reaction to Star Trek surprised the actors, I think. Certainly, they didn't consider that job (Star Trek) as their best work and yet they're all defined by that body of work.
ReplyDeletePersonally, I loved all the Star Trek shows. I think my favorite was actually Star Trek the Next Generation. Hard to pick out one episode but one I did like was the one where Picard and an alien had no common ground to communicate and yet they had to find one to survive.
I think the reaction to the show did take everyone by surprise. I mean, technically it's a really cheesy show. Just look at the fight between that Gorn and Kirk. It's ridiculous, but the themes were very strong -- like in mythology -- and that's what fans continue to take from it.
DeleteI missed a lot of the Next Generation because of life, but I know he's a fav with so many.
My favorite character was Picard. Patrick Stewart was just awesome. Spock comes in second. All that logic ... I have none, LOL! I liked William Shatner better in Boston Legal. He played much the same kind of arrogant character, yet in BL he was funny.
ReplyDeleteStewart has that great accent and way of speaking that really says captain! And Spock is, um, fascinating. :)
DeleteMan, that sounds so good! Love what you took from it :)
ReplyDeleteYeah, I was surprised when the documentary turned to Joseph Campbell. That was an aha moment for sure. Started taking notes.:)
DeleteI love Star Trek going 'intelligentsia' (there is a reason for tv after all). There is a theme that prevails in that series, that of discovery and finding what's out there where no man has gone (or woman either). Spock was my fave, didn't care for the young Kirk that much, he's gotten better with age. I didn't watch the later series, kids controlled the tv during those times.
ReplyDeleteWhat appeals? (altho' I've never gone to a trekkie convention, they have them here in Vancouver) and a good friend (blogger) does go to them and does come in costume. She enjoys it, and their young child is getting into it as well.
My heroes are probably based on Spock, with a tiny bit of Kirk thrown in just to shake it up. Great post, LG. My sis is a big Trekkie fan, also.
That's the other thing -- the exploration. They interviewed this very mild and meek woman who talked about how she watched the first moon landing on television as a kid and then got hooked on Star Trek. You think, okay, she's a space nut, and that's cool. Then she reveals she's now a software engineer who works on the Hubble telescope!!! I mean, she really took those themes of exploration to heart. :D
DeleteI like Spock too, and I really like the guy who plays him in the new movies. Well done.
Believe it or not I've never really seen Star Trek. I had to watch an episode of Next Generation for a Morality class I took, but that's about as far as my knowledge of it goes :P
ReplyDeleteI cannot, for the life of me, remember what the episode was even about. I remember actually kind of liking it though :D
Whaaaaaaat?!!? Surely you've seen the movies? Wow. And how interesting that they showed it in a morality class. There are entire psychology classes that teach about it as well. :)
DeleteI hadn't heard about this documentary, but I'm going to have to add it to my "to watch" list. I am woefully inadequate when it comes to Star Trek, but a good friend of mine is a huge Trekkie. It's always so interesting to me how some stories like this take on such a life of their own. I can imagine no one working on the original series ever dreamed what it would turn into. I just think it's fascinating to consider what makes some stories touch people to that extent, while others are enjoyable while they air but then are quickly forgotten. I love the idea of touching on those universal themes. Interesting post!
ReplyDeleteHave a great weekend, LG! :)
I think it aired on cable over the summer, but it's on Netflix now. I used to watch the old episodes with my dad after school. I loved it. I don't think I knew why at the time, other than it was entertaining, but I realize now I really did latch onto a lot of those messages of equality.
DeleteMy favorite episode was the Abrams movie, and, still, I can't think too hard about that one or my head starts to hurt. Red matter? Seriously?
ReplyDeleteI watched Star Trek when I was a kid (like, 5) and enjoyed it, but it just went away when Star Wars came out. When Next Gen started, I walked into the room during the premiere as the saucer was separating and gagged and walked back out and never watched it while it was running as a series. I have seen some of it now (because of my wife), but Star Trek has never been my thing.
Oh, I loved that movie too. And the next one is about to come out. With Benedict Cumberbatch as the villain. Mwahahahah.
DeleteAlso, just as an aside, George Lucas has said that it was Joseph Campbell's book, The Hero Has a Thousand Faces, that inspired his Star Wars story.
Well, not inspired exactly, but he used it in developing the ideas for the characters. I mean, it's not like he was reading Campbell and went, "Ooh! I have an idea." Rather, he had an idea and started trying to write it and broke out the Campbell to figure out what he was doing.
DeleteGet Fanboys. Shatner makes an excellent cameo appearance. Man, I need to watch that again. Good thing I own it!
Okay, you're right, maybe not inspired. Guided would be a better word for it.
DeleteOh! Have you seen Fanboys? If not, you really need to see that.
ReplyDeleteHave not seen it, but may have to now. :)
DeleteI'm with Andrew... my favorite episode was the Abrams movie too. But as a rabid Firefly fan, I totally get it.
ReplyDeleteI was gonna say...you're probably one of the most rabid Firefly fans I've run into online. I won't ask if you have the outfits. :P
DeleteOf all the sci-fi shows ever on TV, Firefly had the most solid and entertaining start. Probably, the second would be Babylon 5. I will never quit being upset with Fox over that whole thing.
DeleteOoh, never watched Babylon 5. And I've only gotten through a few episodes of Firefly. That's another one of those shows that didn't last long, but people just went crazy over it.
DeleteBabylon 5 has some of the best writing in sci-fi ever. The whole 5 year story arc was written ahead of time, and everything was planned out. It's really an amazing story. You have to kind of get over the bad effects (it was the first show to really use digital technology that way, and it shows), and just watch the story.
ReplyDeleteWas just reading a recap of the show, and it sounds like it had a lot of really strong themes in it. But, see, isn't that what's so interesting? They tried to go for those universal themes like other shows/stories and it didn't necessarily work. Hmmmm...fascinating.
DeleteWell, it worked for 5 years. That's a pretty successful TV show.
DeleteLonger than Star Trek. :)
DeleteI can't pick just one episode. There were too many good ones. Even loved Star Trek, Next Generation. But I'm still feeling the love the Shat-Man.ha He is awesome.
ReplyDeleteI don't have a clue why these stories affect so many people in this way, other than they are AMAZING stories. Leaving mine up to the Force.
I know! I've forgotten a lot of them, too, but I keep being reminded of more and more that I loved. Also, it was something my father and I had in common, so I think I have very nostalgic memories of the show. :)
DeleteAnd you'll have to shout your admiration for THE KIRK a little louder. His awesomeness really is that loud. :P
Excellent post! I haven't watch many of the original Trek episodes, but I love the storytelling on other sci-fi shows like Firefly and Farscape. I think, at a high level, we fall in love with those stories because the characters and stakes become so personal. Yes, they're all trying to save the world (or galaxies), but they're also trying to save friends and principles on a smaller, personal level that really speaks to us.
ReplyDeleteI don't even know if they still show the episodes in reruns. Maybe on Nickelodeon? I have no idea. I know you can watch them on Netflix and probably Youtube, but I doubt many people are out there searching for old television shows to watch. STill, it really was/is a phenomenon that has transcended generations in an odd way, and probably for a lot of reasons you just stated.
DeleteI can't remember if I admitted this online before, but Mr. Spock was my first crush when I was four years old. Kind of funny, considering how Vulcan's aren't emotional. :) I didn't get to watch the television shows much, but I saw all the movies!
ReplyDeleteI also really got into Star Wars the Next Generation. I did go to a convention where Patrick Stewart was the headliner. I had to - it was Patrick Stewart, after all - and I must say it was cool! There were Klingons there, though. That was some serious cosplay!
Hey, Spock had his charms. :D
DeleteAnd, wow, you've actually been to a convention?! You're the first person I know of who has been to one. Excellent. Wow, that would have made a fun blog post with photos of Klingons in the lobby drinking their Starbucks. :)
I rememebr that old SNL skit. One of the best classics of all time. Thanks for sharing it again!
ReplyDeleteFascinating portrayal of the evil Kirk, as first seen in episode #33. :P
DeleteHow much did I enjoy this? More than nerds can say. (Sorry.) Hmmm, it'd be hard to pick just one favorite episode. Maybe "The Trouble With Tribbles"? (Only because that's the only title I actually remember!)
ReplyDeleteY'know, although it never occurred to me to learn how to speak Klingon or to get decked out in costume to attend a convention, Star Trek fans who do aren't any stranger than people involved with Civil War, and other military era, re-enactments groups, or Renaissance groups, etc. Whatever floats their boat.
Yeah, I've never been one of those fans who dresses up as a character or goes to midnight book release parties, but I very much understand the impulse. In a lot of ways it's not that much different from some of the writing conferences I go to, because, really, it's about a sort of fellowship with like-minded people as much as anything. The costuming just includes a more dramatic involvement from the participant. :)
DeleteI love the Shatner and the old Star Treks. They are so universal, ideal in many ways, but the characters were so much like us we could relate.
ReplyDeleteGorn was a great episode. My favorite is Plato's Stepchildren.
You know, that's probably a great distinction. Those characters really were very much like us, and I think that was a conscientious decision by Roddenberry. And that's one of the things I liked about Abrams movie, seeing Kirk on his motorcycle in Iowa (?) before heading to Starfleet Command school. :)
DeleteAnd Plato's Stepchildren, which I just looked up, is the episode with the infamous interracial kiss!! Which I incorrectly said was the first on TV but wasn't. But it was still a shocker, I'm sure!
I support all things Shatner. I think I'll throw that doc on my queue. I tried to watch his ones on Captains, but couldn't get into it. I doubt you can plan to write something that becomes a world of its own. I wish you could. I'm also sad Twilight is in that category, though it most definitely is.
ReplyDeleteYeah, I haven't seen the Captains one. And this one would have lost my interest if it hadn't turned to the storytelling angle and the connection to myth and society as a whole. That really got me thinking.
DeleteAnd I apologize for including Twilight, but in my defense I did leave off Fifty Shades of Gray. :P
Hi Luanne .. you've hit the spot here! I could never get to grips with Star Trek in any form .. I'll watch odd bits here and there .. had to look at your Gorn clip - sums it up for me!
ReplyDeleteInteresting about the storyline and character creation .. if it pops up here I'll have a listen .. well certainly my take on some programmes has opened my eyes to different aspects so can understand your change in your thinking aspect .. worth considering ..
Have a great weekend ... Hilary
Hilary - That Gorn clip is ridiculous! But it's also part of why I loved the original Star Trek. So corny, but for some reason that was very appealing when I was a kid. Maybe because it resembled the way we played in real life. LOL.
ReplyDeleteYep, I'm a Trekkie too -- and I like how Shatner has changed his tune in his old age. He also put together a documentary called The Captains where he interviews each of the series' captains and admits he sees and "gets" what Star Trek is all about now: a better future, for one thing. One of my favorite episodes is "Balance of Power" -- probably the only one where Kirk doesn't smile once.
ReplyDeleteWell, what a wasted life if he didn't take the time to figure out why millions of fans continue to love what he did in that series. And what a unique club to be in -- Star Trek Captain. It's almost as exclusive as the living presidents club. :P
DeleteWhat a cool post! How fascinating. Yeah, it's so weird how you never know what will resonate with people--with the largest percentage of people. Although I think it's true that a book or movie or series has to speak to the universal human experience to catch on like Star Trek or Harry Potter, I also think that luck and timing have a lot to do with it as well.
ReplyDeleteOh, I think you're right that timing or some element of "hive mind" has to be in place for the right story to click at the right time. Sometimes it just seems so random.
Delete